Hotel TerracottaIndependent travel guide
Palm-lined Key West street near the water

Key West · checked October 2026

Key West gay resorts, compared

Three places to stay and one to ignore: a men-only resort on Fleming Street, a men’s guesthouse above a Duval Street bar, an inclusive adults-only guesthouse, and Equator, which closed in January 2025.

Photo: Lisa Davidson / Unsplash

Researched by the Hotel Terracotta editorial desk · Edited by · Resort status, prices and review totals rechecked October 2026 · How we work

Quick answer

Island House, New Orleans House or Alexander’s?

Choose Island House on Fleming Street when you want a men-only resort that keeps you on the property: pool, 24-hour cafe and bar, health club, steam room and sauna. Choose New Orleans House on Duval Street when the nightlife is the point; it sits above the Bourbon Street Pub, and its clothing-optional backyard has a bar open until 4 am. Choose Alexander’s for a calm guesthouse that takes adults of every gender, where clothing is optional only on the sundecks, according to guest reviews.

PropertyGuest ratingPrice / nightRoomsGuest policyClothing-optional where
Island House★ 4.6 (737, Tripadvisor)$369–769 for two39Men only on the clothing-optional sideThroughout that side
New Orleans House8.2/10 (150, Booking.com)Not published; shown on booking sites by dateNot publishedGay men, 21+; “all-welcome” rooms by phoneBackyard: pool, jacuzzi, Garden Bar
Alexander’s Guesthouse★ 4.9 (1,475, Tripadvisor)$161–62317Adults 21+, any genderSundecks, per guest reviews; not stated on its site
Equator ResortClosed——Formerly men onlyClosed January 9, 2025

Island House rates from its own rooms page; Alexander’s range from Tripadvisor. Ratings come from different platforms and scales, so compare them within a row, not across rows. Checked October 29–30, 2026. Equator is listed only because old directory pages still show it.

Three different trips

A resort, a party house or a quiet guesthouse

All three are in Old Town within walking distance of Duval Street, and they still have very little in common.

Men-only resort

Island House

Thirty-nine rooms around a heated pool, a 24-hour poolside cafe and bar, and a 24-hour health club with a steam room, sauna and two jacuzzis. A daily happy hour for registered guests and pool parties on Wednesdays and Sundays give it a built-in social calendar.

Read the full profile →
On Duval Street

New Orleans House

A guesthouse above the Bourbon Street Pub with a 24-hour pool, a 15-man jacuzzi and the Garden Bar in a clothing-optional backyard. Continental breakfast and happy-hour drink specials are included. Light sleepers should look elsewhere.

Read the full profile →
Quiet & inclusive

Alexander’s

Seventeen rooms, breakfast and happy-hour cocktails, and the highest guest rating of the three. It welcomes adults of any gender and works as a calm base for walking the town rather than a place to spend the whole day.

Read the full profile →

The phrase is not enough

Where clothing is optional matters

Island House is clothing-optional throughout its men-only side; Florida law still requires shorts and shoes in the gym. Women and mixed groups stay in separate apartments across Stickney Lane.

New Orleans House limits it to the backyard: the pool, jacuzzi and Garden Bar. Its site offers “all-welcome” rooms by phone without saying whether those guests use the backyard, so a mixed group should ask before booking.

Alexander’s doesn’t publish a clothing policy at all. Guest reviews place clothing-optional use on the sundecks, which makes it the right match for an LGBTQ+ guesthouse with some optional space, not for a nude-resort stay.

For etiquette, phones, consent and packing, read the first-time clothing-optional guide before you go.

Price and practical details

Comparing the cost

Only Island House publishes its own rate range. For the other two, the fair comparison is the same dates on the same booking site, with taxes included.

$369–769

Island House

Per night for two on its own site, plus $50 for each extra guest. Cancel by phone at least 15 days out to get the deposit back, minus $50.

$161–623

Alexander’s

Tripadvisor’s range. Breakfast and happy-hour cocktails are included, which narrows the gap with pricier stays.

By date

New Orleans House

No rates or cancellation terms on its own site. Booking sites show prices for specific dates; terms vary by room.

Do not book an old listing

Equator Resort closed on January 9, 2025

Equator was a men-only clothing-optional resort on Fleming Street from 1997. Its closure was announced in February 2024 and took effect on January 9, 2025, but old directories and archived booking pages still surface in search results.

Don’t pay through any page that presents Equator as open. The Equator page has the details and sources.

If Key West prices don’t work, our Fort Lauderdale comparison covers three men-only clothing-optional guesthouses there.

Questions

What gay resorts are open in Key West?

Island House and New Orleans House are open men-only clothing-optional options, and Alexander’s Guesthouse is an adults-only LGBTQ+ guesthouse for every gender. Equator Resort closed on January 9, 2025.

Is Island House Key West clothing-optional?

Yes, throughout its men-only side, except the gym, where shorts and shoes are required.

Is New Orleans House clothing-optional?

In its backyard, which has the pool, a 15-man jacuzzi and the Garden Bar. The guesthouse sits above the Bourbon Street Pub on Duval Street.

Is Alexander’s Guesthouse clothing-optional?

Its website doesn’t state a clothing policy; guest reviews describe clothing as optional on the sundecks only. It takes adults 21 and over of any gender.

Which is quietest?

Alexander’s. New Orleans House is the opposite, with a bar downstairs and a backyard bar open until 4 am.